In the Wake of AI, What Is the Future of Mathematics?

The Clay Mathematics Institute posed seven Millennium Prize problems in 2000, which were mathematical challenges so difficult that those who solved them would receive $1 million.
One of these, the Navier-Stokes problem, was solved by OpenAI in September.
This event shook the mathematical community, calling into question the importance of mathematicians going forward. While some meet the incoming artificial intelligence with fear, others still believe in an optimistic viewpoint.
"Do we bury our head in the sand, or do we embrace it?" said Dr. Ryan Fox, professor of mathematical education at Belmont.
With the rapid evolution of AI, it seems daunting to enter a field that is being shaped so much and so fast. But some in the math community see this as a golden time for mathematicians to find their importance in the digital age.
"Now is the best time in the recent past to go into math. We are at an artificial juncture. Where does our community want to go?" said Dr. Adam Cartisano, professor of algebraic geometry and intersection theory at Belmont.
One of the biggest fears regarding AI is that it will take over the need for human expression.
In an opinion piece for The New York Times, author and podcaster Walter Isaacson wrote that despite the growing fears, dangers and prospects that this AI revolution can bring, the human voice is still relevant.
"A society in which machines do everything for us would provide abundance while depriving us of agency and meaning," Isaacson said.
A form of comparison made to AI's role in math is the calculator.
In the 1960s, mathematicians and educators worried that the widespread implementation of calculators would take away the critical thinking that comes with math.
In 1995, three researchers from the Educational Testing Service conducted an experiment to study how calculators affected the scores of a mathematical reasoning test.
The average SAT score for students with calculators was 474, while the experimental group without calculators scored an average of 472.
"The use of calculators resulted in a modest score increase on a test composed of the type of mathematical reasoning items found on the SAT, although effect on individual items ranged from positive through neutral to negative," they wrote in the conclusion.
But even with how commonplace calculators have become, it has not reduced the importance for mathematicians, and the same can be said for AI.
This is because AI produces results, but it takes a human mind to put those results into use. A point that is reflected in the Navier-Stokes problem.
"If you ask it, 'how did you solve the Navier-Stokes Millennium Problem?' It gives a crappy explanation. It can’t explain itself very well," said mathematician Steven Strogatz in a podcast episode about the incorporation of AI in math.
While AI solving mathematical processes instantly sounds nice on paper, there is a real art in math that AI cannot replicate.
"The person going through the process of solving a complex equation is similar to a musician going on a different key and being successful," Cartisano said.
While AI tends to bring about strong feelings on both sides of the table, its implementation in math is far from black and white.
"There are good uses to deepen understanding or improve how you learn," said Dr. Brad Schleben, associate professor of mathematics and chair of the Department of Mathematics & Computer Science at Belmont.
So, the issue is not what AI is going to do to math, but how mathematicians will use the benefits of a human mind going forward.
As easy as it can be to give into the capabilities of AI and allow it to take over mundane tasks, it should not come at the risk of taking away human effort, Cartisano said.
"Do you want to walk around blindfolded your whole life?" Cartisano said.
Written by Trey Sullivan



Comments